Stop Chasing New Customers. Your List Is Hiding $1M in Plain Sight.
- Kyle Olmstead
- Sep 2
- 3 min read
Updated: Sep 19
Seriously. Most brands are desperate for acquisition while letting the goldmine in their own inbox rot. It’s wild. Ads are cool. Paid campaigns feel sexy. But here’s the truth: your existing email and SMS subscribers? They’re a treasure trove you’ve been ignoring.
And I don’t mean just sending them “Hey, buy again” emails and hoping for magic. I mean systematically uncovering dormant, high-value customers, segmenting them, and designing flows that drive repeat revenue... all without spending a single extra ad dollar.
Let me show you how this works, the smart way.
Step 1: Find the hidden treasure
First, identify the people already invested in your brand but haven’t purchased recently. We’re talking the ones who opened, clicked, maybe even dropped into carts, but went silent.
Pro tip: Don’t just look at last purchase date. Look at:
Engagement score: Opens + clicks over the last 12 months.
Purchase frequency & AOV: Who bought premium products but hasn’t returned?
Product affinity: What did they love before? What’s most relevant to them now?
Example: Imagine a fitness wearable brand with 18,000 inactive subscribers. Suppose 40% of them had purchased at least once, with an average order value of $175. By isolating that group, you could identify exactly who to target first for the highest ROI.
Step 2: Segment like a surgeon
Once you know who’s hiding revenue, don’t blast them all with the same message. That’s like shouting in a crowded gym, everyone hears you, but no one listens.
Segment based on:
Purchase history: VIP buyers vs. one-timers.
Engagement level: Opens frequently vs. cold for 6+ months.
Behavioral triggers: Abandoned carts, downloaded content, clicked links but didn’t convert.
When you segment properly, you can tailor exactly what they need to see to feel compelled to buy again.
Step 3: Design reactivation flows
This is where the magic happens. Instead of begging for attention, create automated journeys that speak to them like a human, not a robot.
Here are some high-performing flows:
“We Miss You” + Value Add
Subject: “Still obsessed with your fitness goals?”
Copy: Friendly nudge, quick tip or free resource.
CTA: Shop a recommended product or return to your dashboard.
Social Proof & FOMO
Subject: “See why 5,000 people upgraded last month”
Copy: Highlight trending products, top-sellers, or limited-time perks.
CTA: Purchase or claim an exclusive offer.
VIP Win-Back
Segment: High-spend buyers who went cold
Subject: “We noticed you haven’t been around and we miss you”
Copy: Personalized reminder of what they loved, plus loyalty points or freebie.
CTA: Reactivate purchase with exclusive reward.
Result: Brands often see 20–40% of dormant subscribers re-engage within the first 30 days of a smartly structured flow.
Step 4: Measure, tweak, repeat
Numbers don’t lie. Track:
Open & click rates: Are they engaging with the content?
Revenue per email: Did the flow actually drive repeat purchases?
Churn reduction: Are subscribers staying longer?
If something underperforms, don’t panic. Test subject lines, incentives, timing. Automation gives you repeatable revenue without manual work, and you don’t have to spend a cent on new traffic.
Quick Takeaways
Dormant subscribers = hidden revenue. Don’t ignore them.
Segmentation matters. One size fits no one.
Automation = repeatable revenue. Set it and optimize.
Measure everything. Revenue per email > vanity metrics.
Personalization works. Speak human, not robot.
Even if your acquisition campaigns are performing, you’re leaving money on the table if you haven’t reactivated your old subscribers.
💡 When’s the last time you really looked at the revenue hiding in your own list? Could a few smart flows unlock thousands, or even millions, in repeat purchases? If the idea of turning cold subscribers into loyal buyers sounds good, maybe it’s time to rethink your approach. Inboxercise can help you find the dormant gold, segment smartly, and automate flows that actually work without blowing your ad budget.
Comments